Thin and thick cylinders
Pressure pipes, water tanks, boiler shells, penstocks and gas cylinders carry internal pressure that pushes the wall outward. If the wall is thin compared with the diameter (thickness less than about one twentieth of the diameter), stress across the wall can be taken as uniform. Cut the cylinder lengthwise and balance pressure against wall tension to get the hoop (circumferential) stress p d / (2t). Cut it across and the longitudinal stress is half that, p d / (4t). Hoop stress governs, so pipes split along their length, as anyone who has seen a frozen water pipe knows.
A thin sphere has equal stress in every direction, p d / (4t), so for the same pressure and stress a sphere needs half the thickness of a cylinder. That is why large gas holders are spherical. Joint efficiency reduces the effective thickness where seams are riveted or welded.
For thick cylinders, such as high-pressure hydraulic pipes and gun barrels, stress varies across the wall. Lamé's equations give radial and hoop stress as A ± B/r². Hoop stress is highest at the inner surface. Adding thickness has diminishing returns, so very high pressures use compound cylinders shrunk one over another, or autofrettage, to pre-compress the bore. Civil engineers meet these ideas in penstock design, pressure mains and prestressed concrete tanks.
Check the ratio of thickness to diameter first; it tells you whether the quick thin-wall formulas are good enough.
Thin cylinder hoop: σh = p d / (2 t η)Longitudinal: σl = p d / (4 t)Thin sphere: σ = p d / (4 t)Lamé (thick): σr = A − B/r², σh = A + B/r²
Using the longitudinal stress formula for the hoop direction, which halves the required thickness and is unsafe.
Problem. A steel penstock of 1.8 m diameter carries water at 1.2 MPa. Allowable hoop stress is 120 MPa and weld efficiency 0.9. Find the wall thickness.
- t = p d / (2 σ η) = 1.2 × 1 800 / (2 × 120 × 0.9).
- t = 2 160 / 216 = 10 mm.
- Add a corrosion allowance, say 2 mm, giving 12 mm.
- Check t/d = 12/1 800, well under 1/20, so thin-wall theory applies.
Answer. About 12 mm including corrosion allowance
Quick quiz
1Which stress governs a thin cylinder?
Hoop stress, twice the longitudinal stress.
2Why is a sphere more efficient for pressure?
Its stress is pd/4t in all directions, half the cylinder hoop stress.
3Where is hoop stress largest in a thick cylinder?
At the inner surface.
- IS 3370 (series) (India): Concrete structures for storage of liquids.
Clauses and documents to read
- IS 3370 (Part 2):2009 (reinforced and prestressed liquid-retaining structures)
Cited by number and clause only. We do not reproduce clause text, tables or figures (BIS Act 2016, s.10(5) and s.11). Check the current edition and amendments before use.
References and further reading
Standard texts, listed in no order of merit. We do not copy text, figures, tables or solved problems from any book; our explanations and examples are original.
- J. M. Gere, B. J. Goodno, Mechanics of Materials, Cengage, latest edition.
- F. P. Beer, E. R. Johnston, J. T. DeWolf, Mechanics of Materials, McGraw Hill, latest edition.
- E. P. Popov, Engineering Mechanics of Solids, Prentice Hall, 2nd edition.
Free and official sources
Found an error? Write to indiacongroupofengineers [at] gmail [dot] com. For corrections and feedback. We never ask for payment or personal details.